Submission Guidelines
PANORAMA ECONOMICO througth this guidelines inform about how submissions are required.
Extension
Submissions must be less than 30 pages, including figures, tables, equations, referencies and appendices. Times New Roman font, 12 points, 1.5 spaced. Files format in Microsoft Word, OpenOffice, RTF or WordPerfect. For now PANORAMA ECONOMICO is not receiving LaTex submissions.
Languaje
PANORAMA ECONOMICO accept submissions in Spanish and English. It is mandatory that the next content uploaded must be in Spanish and English:
- Submission title
- Abstract
- Keywords
- JEL classification (https://www.aeaweb.org/econlit/jelCodes.php?view=jel )
Topics
PANORAMA ECONOMICO is a journal wich receives submissions with scientifyc rigour, original and unpublished, not applied for review simultaneosly in other journals, in Spanish or English in the next areas:
- General economics and education
- Schools of economic thought
- Mathematics methods and quantitave mathematics
- Microeconomics
- Macroeconomics and monetary economics
- International economics
- Finantial economis
- Public economics
- Labor and demographic economics
- Business management and bussines economics; Consumer behavior; Account
- Law and economics
- Industrial organization
- History economics
- Development, technology change and grow
- Politics economics and system economics
- Enviromental economics and ecology
- Urban, rural and regional economy
Types of submissions
PANORAMA ECONOMICO acept the next topics in research for evaluate and publish
Research articles: Open section. Submissions must describe the novelty about the paper. This papers are reviewed by peer review process.
Review: Open section. This papers make a comprehensive analysis about some interesting topic for the journal. Review is only by invitation from editorial committe or journal editor. This papers are reviewed by peer review process
Redaction style
Submission must be wrote using Times New Roman a 12 points, justified, interline 1.5 witouht space between paragraph or lines break. Pages must be enumerated since first to last one.
Acronyms
In case of acronyms or abbreviations, first time they must be presented with full name and after that inside parentesis. Example, Producto Interno Bruto (PIB).
Guidelines for manuscritps
PANORAMA ECONOMICO journal follow the APA 7th edition norms (APA 7th edition). However, next lines shows some general aspects.
Format
Usually, manuscript are submitted using Times New a 13 points, bold, justified the next title sections:
- Abstract (Spanish and English)
- Keywords
- JEL classification
- Structure of submition
- Introduction
- Literature review
- Methodology
- Results
- Discussion
- Conclusions
- Acknowledgements
- Founding
- References
- Apendices
Title of submition (heading level 1) must be in Times New Roman 14 points, bold, centered. Typographical markers in simple space, in case of a list use numered markers with simple spaced, other cases author are free to select type of marker but following same style in all manuscript.
Subsections
Sections in the manuscript could be ordered as follor:title (heading level 1), inside sections (heading level 2), subsections (heading level 3) maximum two levels in content (i.e. header level 3). For section Times New Roman 12 points, bold, justified. For subsection, Times New Roman 12 points, italic, justified. All subsections must be numered. Example:
1. Introducción (heading level 1)
1.1. Regularidades del contexto en México (heading level 2)
1.2. Características del contexto en Puebla (heading level 2)
1.2.1. Características económicas del crecimiento del PIB (heading level 3)
Figures, tables and equations
Figures
Figure is considered as: chart, diagram, map, graphic, photografic or another illustration. Figures must be presented in JPG or PNG (300 pp at least). In the text, refer any figure by its number, example: Figure 1 or (Figure 1). Figures must be placed closed their first callout. If submission is aceppted, journal PANORAMA ECONOMICO has the right of modify figure position for editorial situations.
Figure number must be upper image. The word "Figure" must be bold, arabic number and consecutive order in ascendent. Times New Roman 11 points. Title below the figure number, one double-spaced line below in italic, title case (you can find more information abour title case in APA 7th Title Case Capitalization). It is recommend that title be descriptive and small.
After title, image can be added, this could be a graphic, chart, draw, photographic or other illustration. Add a legend if necessary.
Finally, IF IT IS NECESSARY add a NOTE. There are the next type of notes: general, specific and probability. This notes are below of content and are wrote only if image can not explain it. Again, include NOTE only if are necessary.
Example:
Figure 1
Figure Example for PANORAMA ECONOMICO journal

Note. Figure was made with Microsoft Excel.
Each figure must be attached in platform, figure could be in JPG or PNG at 300 pp or more. Algo, could be included in an Excel file. Image not be exceed 1 MB (only extraordinary cases could be more, example, photograpics). If image is not original from author this must be their attribution or Copyright. Information about figures and their format could be found in APA 7th edition.
Tables
Tables must be placed close to their first callout. In the body text it is mandatory place number of table refered; example, Table 1 or (Table 1). All tables must be editable.
Table number must be placed above of table information. Bold and arabic number in consecutive way.
Table title below the table number, one double-spaced line below in italic, title case (APA 7th Title Case Capitalization). It is recommend that title be descriptive and small.
It is recommend see more examples in tables examples APA 7th.
Bordes or lines are used for separate superior and inferior body table. Below of columns headings and above principla heading. Use only necessary lines.
If submissions is acepted, PANORAMA ECONOMICO journal could modify ubication of table if edition requires.
Table 1
Example of Table for PANORAME ECONOMICO Journal
| Variable | Modelo 1 | Modelo 2 | ||||||
| B | β | SE | B | β | SE | |||
| Constante | 1.23** | 0.12 | 9.87 | 0.78 | ||||
| ABCDa | 0.123 | 0.01 | 0.34 | -0.65* | 0.198 | 0.91 | ||
| FGHI | -0.456 | 0.23 | 0.56 | -0.432 | 0.76 | 0.23 | ||
| R2 | 0.35 | 0.46 | ||||||
Note. Random numbers. a Superscript lowercase letter are used to make extra explanation.
Equations
Equations must be editable, usign MathType like or editor from Microsoft Word. Equations must be close to their callout, and named as: Equation 1 or (Equation 1). All equations must be numered with arabic numbers and inside of parenthesis near to right margin of page.

In case of equation (or equations) are not possible present in one line, it is possible use two o more lines, if this make a clear reading. Equation 2 is an example where displayed equations use only one number for all them.

However, if a sequence is required, consecutively number can be used (equations 3.1 to 3.3).

Submissions
Register
All submissions must be trought https://www.revistapanoramaeconomico.mx/index.php/PE/about/submissions
It is important that authors must be registered on https://www.revistapanoramaeconomico.mx/index.php/PE/user/register
The submission must have a corresponding author.
Anonymous submission
Submissions must be divided in 4 parts. First, full manuscript, with no names, affiliation, water mark, comments, email or other information that expose identification of authors. First page must have:
- Title in Spanish and English
- Abstracti Spanish and English
- Keywords in Spanish and English
- Jel classification in Spanish and English
Second, cover letter containing for each author named: current affiliation, email (institutional preferred), country, ORCID.
Name: full name witout acronyms or abbreviations.
Affiliation and email: It is mandatory for all authors.
Third one, file containing audiovisual materials. If manuscript is approveed tihis material will be used in layout. We prefer an Excel file but authors can upluad Power Point, Corel Draw or JPG with at least 300pp.
Finally, fourth, a cover letter with heredity rigths (carta de cesión de derechos) in Spanish.
It is important point out that manuscript, cover letter with authors identification and heredity rights are mandatory.
Form
Title: must be in Spanish and English. Keep title short, focused and include key terms. Not be greater than 15 words and avoid titles with poetry or metaphoric. Also, avoid phrases similar to:
- Study about…
- To be or not to be.
- Los años del Z45 en los bosques de IAO
Keyword: Spanish and English. Not more than 5 keywords. Kewywords helps in metadata search. Keywords are words, acronyms that describe important aspects. Help readers to find work during searching.
JEL classification: Spanish and English. At least one code and no more than five (https://www.aeaweb.org/econlit/jelCodes.php?view=jel )
Abstract: text must be between 100 and 250 words and contains the next parts inside the text:
- Objective: aims and/or goals of study. Explicit, rationale, clear and direct, main hypotheses.
- Method: material, description of techniques used, sample, data-analytic method, etc...
- Results: report findings, data analysis.
- Conclusions: implications, cons, programs or policy benefits.
Abstract is a brief, comprehensive symmary ot the previusly comment contents of the paper.
Submission format
Submissions send to PANORAMA ECONOMICO must follow the next format:
- Introduction: This section presents problems/aim that starter the passion for the problem, provide motives for make the research. This section shows with actual references and discussions the main context of the research. Introduction must be wrote explicit, clear and focused.
- Literature review or state of art: This section shows information about the topic of the submission. Usually describes paper researchs and specialiced books which support the submission. Literature review must describe solutions and questions from other researchers. It is important that compare results frfom other researchers and their contributions.
- Method: This section shows how this research was made. Method section must shows process, techniques, method, software, variables, sampling and other aspects which helped to obtain the results. This section must be capable to reproduce the results and data mencioned.
- Results: This section shows the results of this research. As a suggestions, results could be presented with tables, figures and equations. The aim of this section is shows that results in a direct way and clear the results.
- Discussion: In this section discuss similarities and differences with literature, researchs and other existents topics. It is importat point out that the novelty of the submission.
- Conclussions: This section shows implications of the research. In addition, shows future researchs or programs.
- Agreements: This section is optional.
- Founding: This section is optional
- References: All submissions sent to PANORAMA ECONOMICO must be follow the APA 7th edition (https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition )
- Appendix or supplemental materials: This sections shows text, discussions or proofs that it is important for understand the research but it is not possible to include inside the body of the submission. This section must be numered as A1, A2 and so on.
Reference Style
Submissions to PANORAMA ECONOMICO must follow the APA 7th editon guidelines (https://apastyle.apa.org/products/publication-manual-7th-edition )
References
It is important that all references must be wrote properly.
Authors are responsible for all information in their reference list.
All cites must have their references and vice versa. When present references provide the DOI or URL either.
Cites
There are two types of cite: textual and parenthetical. To find more information see APa 7th edition.
In general,
| Reference | Ríos, Humberto (2006). Innovación tecnológica y productividad sectorial en la economía mexicana: evidencia regional. Panorama Económico, 1(2), 62-84. https://doi.org/10.29201/peipn.v1i2.253 |
| Parenthetical cite | (Ríos, 2006) |
| Narrative cite | Ríos (2006) |
For the text use both narrative and parenthetical citation. Also for the writting can use paraphrase which repeat the idea of other author (or previous researchs) and direct citation. Direct citation reproduce textually words from other works. An appropiate citatioen level use both parenthetican and narrative citation, more in Appropriate Level of Citation
An appropiate level of citation use:
- Paraphrases
- Direct citation
- Short cites
- Block citation
This styles can be find in chapter 8 of Publication Manual of APA and Consice Guide in chapther 8, also can check the website APA 7th edition.
Some examples will be displayed to help authors, howevera, are encourage to visit APA guidelines website or print version.
The next examples are obteined from APA website APA guidelines.
The short direct citation is less than 40 words and must be placed inside quotation marks. According to APA 7th edition, this cite must provide author name, year and page.
Direct short narrative cite example:
According to Ervin et al., (2018) effective teams can be difficult to describe because “high performance along one domain does not translate to high performance along another” (p. 470).
Direct short parenthetical cite example:
Effective teams can be difficult to describe because “high performance along one domain does not translate to high performance along another” (Ervin et al., 2018, p. 470).
If citation excedes 40 words use in block citation. Do not use quotation marks in text delimitation. Citation starts in a new line, tabulation of 1.25 cm (0.5 inches) since left side. See more in APA 7h edition quotation
Citation in text examples:
|
|
Parenthetical citation |
Narrative citation |
|
One author |
(Rodríguez, 2024, p. 55) |
Rodríguez (2024) |
|
Two authors |
(Rodríguez & García, 2024, p. 55) |
Rodríguez y García (2024) |
|
Three or more |
(Rodríguez et al., 2024, p. 55). |
Rodríguez et al., (2024) |
|
Grupal author with abbreviation First cite After |
(Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía [INEGI], 2022) (INEGI, 2022) |
Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geográfica (INEGI, 2022) INEGI (2022) |
| Grupal author without abbreviation | (Stanford University, 2020) | Estanford University (2020) |
To avoid ambiguous words or redaction it is recommended see the APA 7th edition, charter 8 or Consise guide, chapter 8. Some examples are showed.
One author with same date (multiple cites from same author) it is necessary add one letter at end.
Example
(Aquelarre & Becerra, 2017a)
Aquelarre & Becerra (2017b)
(Centeno, s.f.-a, s.f.-b)
Multiples cites with same idea, place citation in alphabetical order, separated with semmicolon. Firs place citation without date.
Example
- (Adal, s.f., 2018; Becerra, 2017; Centeno, 2023; Zate et al., 2000, in press)
References examples
More information in normas APA 7th edition
- Article
Autohr, A. A. (Year). Article title. Periodic publication title in italic. Number(Volum). page(s). DOI.
Example
Grady, J. S., Her, M., Moreno, G., Perez, C., & Yelinek, J. (2019). Emotions in storybooks: A comparison of storybooks that represent ethnic and racial groups in the United States. Psychology of Popular Media Culture, 8(3), 207–217. https://doi.org/10.1037/ppm0000185
- Books:
Author, A. A. (Year). Publication title in italic. (Ed). Editorial name. DOI.
Example
Jackson, L. M. (2019). The psychology of prejudice: From attitudes to social action (2nd ed.). American Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/0000168-000
- Book chapter
Author, A. A. (Year). Chapter title. InE. E. Editor. Publication title in italic. (pages). Editorial name. DOI.
Aron, L., Botella, M., & Lubart, T. (2019). Culinary arts: Talent and their development. In R. F. Subotnik, P. Olszewski-Kubilius, & F. C. Worrell (Eds.), The psychology of high performance: Developing human potential into domain-specific talent (pp. 345–359). American Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/0000120-016
More examples can be find in normas APA 7th edition or print (Publication manual or Concise guide).